EDIT: Kudos to Camp Trevor Rees-Jones. At 2018, 2019, and 2020 Winter Camps, there was not once a prohibition on wearing hats at meals!
Stop removing hats at (most) meals. It’s silly.
This tradition may be centuries old. Back then, hats shielded you from grit and grime. Polluted air or dirty work made nasty hats. These hats weren’t appropriate at meals.
Today is different. Youth wear hats for sun protection or fashion. Their hats are not nasty. Ha, let me rephrase: they usually don’t project nastiness.
Removing a hat at meals respects nobody. In fact, it is disrespectful to remove a hat. Dead skin and hair would have been contained by the hat. Not so when the hat’s off. Plus, what does the removed hat do? Gets dirty on the table, next to the food, or on the floor.
Web searches mainly find brainless tradition regurgitation. Chowhound has a refreshing view: In Should I Take My Hat Off at a Restaurant?, Helena Echlin says “no” in many cases, including those applicable to most Scouting situations.
Why do some adults bark about hats at meals? Because it’s Grandpa’s rule. Seriously, that’s about it. No emotionally stable cook or server will feel slighted by a hat.
Sure, when crotchety camp staff demand hats come off, it probably needs to happen. Otherwise, don’t waste time teaching that anachronism.
Prepare Scouts for their world, not for Grandpa’s world: don’t worry about hats at meals.
NOTE: I wrote “most” at the top. In the most formal situations, yes, the hat still needs to come off. However, Scouts almost never reaches that level. We’re not finishing school!
Leave a Reply